Skip to main content

Table 3 Characteristics of the included studies in this systematic review

From: Clinical outcomes of contemporary lateral augmentation techniques in primary ACL reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Reference

Type

LOE

Follow-up

Inclusion period

Knees at final FU

Mean Age (y)

Sex (M/F)

Surgical details

ACL

ACL + LA

All

ACL

ACL + LA

ACL

ACL + LA

ACL

ACL + LA

ACL

ACL + LA

  

(Mo)

Start

End

Start

End

       

Graft

ACL graft

AL type

AL graft

Castoldi et al. [1]

RCT

I

232.8

01/1998

09/1999

01/1998

09/1999

80

42

38

NR

NR

NR

NR

BPTB

BPTB

LET

Grac

Ibrahim et al. [26]

RCT

II

27

01/2014

06/2014

01/2014

06/2014

103

50

53

26

26

50/0

53/0

HT

HT

ALLR

Grac

Hamido et al. [18]

RCT

I

60

04/2014

03/2015

04/2014

03/2015

102

52

50

26

24

52/0

50/0

HT

HT

ALLR

Grac

Sonnery-Cottet et al. [55]

Cohort

II

38.4

01/2012

05/2014

01/2012

05/2014

502

176

221

23.5

21.8

116/60

152/69

HT

HT

ALLR

Grac

    

01/2012

05/2014

-

-

-

105

-

22.1

-

96/9

-

BPTB

-

-

-

Goncharov et al. [15]

Cohort

II

24

2014

2015

2014

2015

48

30

18

NR

NR

NR

NR

BPTB

BPTB

ALLR

Grac/SemiT

Helito et al. [21]

Cohort

III

26

01/2011

06/2012

01/2014

06/2015

101

68

33

33.9

33.1

59/9

30/03

HT

HT

ALLR

Grac

Helito et al. [22]

Cohort

III

28.1

01/2011

01/2013

01/2015

08/2016

90

60

30

29.9

27

28/32

13/17

HT

HT

ALLR

Grac

Rowan et al. [50]

Cohort

III

27

NR

NR

NR

NR

171

125

46

29

27

67/58

27/19

HT

HT

LET

ITB

Porter et al. [45]

RCT

II

24

07/2014

01/2017

07/2014

01/2017

51

23

28

22.3

21.8

NR

NR

HT

HT

MITBT

ITB

Getgood et al. [14]

RCT

I

24

01/2014

03/2017

01/2014

03/2017

589

298

291

18.8

19.1

NR

NR

HT

HT

LET

ITB

Vadalà et al. [58]

Cohort

II

44.6

01/2005

12/2006

01/2005

12/2006

55

28

27

28

26

NR

NR

HT

HT

CA

ITB

  1. ACL Anterior Cruciate Ligament, ALLR Anter Lateral Ligament Reconstruction, BPTB Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone, CA Cocker-Arnold (Modified Lemaire procedure), Grac Gracilis, HT Hamstrings Tendon, ITB IlioTibial Band, LA Lateral Augmentation, LET Lateral Extraarticular Tenodesis, LOE Level of Evidenc, MITBT Modified Iliotibial Band Tenodesis, NR Not Reported, RCT Randomized Control Trial, SemiT Semitendinosus